Secure Trading

Bitcoin users may want to trade bitcoin directly with each other in what is known as an over-the-counter market. This topic is a guide on how to set up your online identity and includes some best practices for trading with others in the Bitcoin community.

Peer-to-peer exchanges such as Bisq and Hodl Hodl can be good alternative platforms for direct KYC-less trading. For a full list of no-KYC exchanges see: https://github.com/cointastical/P2P-Trading-Exchanges/

Introduction

Within the Bitcoin community, individuals should be careful with their security and identity, primarily for two reasons:

At this time, there is little in the way of law enforcement. No court has dealt directly with a significant theft of bitcoins or determined Bitcoin's legal status. Bitcoin users are for the most part, on their own.
In lieu of legal action and lack of community trust outside the Bitcoin system itself, one's reputation has become the focus for building trust relationships with others in the community. Traders will take very little risk with new users who have not proven themselves (as one user can easily commit continuous fraud using many different identities.

The Bitcoin community uses a few tools to help protect privacy, and thus identity. The first and most important is a secure computer.

Before proceeding please make sure you have completed the Securing Your Computer guide; this guide assumes that your computer is secure both physically and in software.

If you are trading within Canada you are encouraged to use Interac e-transfer and Clearcoin (now closed) as outlined on this page.

Creating a secure identity

The first step is to create a cryptographically secure public-private key-pair. This will be used as the basis of keeping both your wallet (see Securing your wallet) and your identity secure.

Creating your first PGP key-pair

A PGP key-pair serves two very important functions:

To sign information with an unforgeable signature
To decrypt things that other people encrypt for you

This allows you to both conduct business privately (encryption), and give out promises that you cannot deny making (signature).

Installing GPG

Virtually all GNU/Linux distributions include GPG in their default configurations, though if it isn't, you need to install it from your package manager. Windows and macOS users will need to install additional software.

Microsoft Windows:

On Windows, the recommended package that contains GPG is the Git package by the msysgit project. This package contains a collection of Unix tools that are very useful for any Windows installation.

Navigate to msysgit https://code.google.com/p/msysgit/downloads/list
Select the latest Git package. (Git-1.7.4-preview20110204.exe)
When installing Git on the Adjusting your PATH environment screen, select: Run Git and included Unix tools from the Windows Command Prompt

This option will install both Git and its supporting tools that include gpg into the Windows file PATH. This will enable any Windows application to access GPG.
It is possible that some other software on your system has installed GPG before. If you think this may be the case, it is advised to use the search tool or command prompt to find or run GPG respectively.

After installation, GPG can be used by entering 'gpg' into any Windows Command Prompt (cmd).

Setting up OpenPGP email

Once you have GPG installed on your system, it is recommended that you use Thunderbird that works on both Windows and Linux systems:

All:

Install Thunderbird: https://www.mozillamessaging.com/en-GB/
Setup your email account with Thunderbird.
Install the Enigmail plugin for Thunderbird: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/addon/enigmail/

Upon loading Enigmail, Thunderbird will ask you to make a new ‘identity,’ follow this wizard and you will have created your identity.
You should backup your private key in a secure place.
Secondary, you should create a revocation certificate and store that in a different secure place (maybe print it out and store it in your fire safe).

Register with [#bitcoin-otc]

Follow the guide here: http://wiki.bitcoin-otc.com/wiki/Using_bitcoin-otc

Register the same username at the popular places:

Use a strong and different password for each of these places, keeping your passwords in a secure place. This will allow other people in the community to track you across the different Bitcoin related sites. Also making identity theft online more challenging.

Best Practices with trading

Use an Escrow Service

Trading can benefit from an escrow service such that bitcoins are help by a third party and disbursed only after contract terms have been met. Individuals willing to act as independent escrow brokers can be found in bitcoin's community.

Use of 2-of-3 multisignature escrow eliminates the risk of the arbitrator stealing the held coins, or losing them to malware or hackers.

Make sure both parties agree to the terms of the trade with signed messages

Get a PGP signed quote, and check the signature.
Send a PGP signed receipt.

This allows either party to go public if the trade has become sour and stops your trading partner from claiming the details of the agreement were somehow different.

Worked Example

Buyer and seller agree on the terms of contract
Both choose a arbitrator
Buyer, seller and arbitrator create public keys and use them to create a 2-of-3 multisig address. The public keys are added to the contract and PGP-signed.
Buyer sends bitcoins as payment to the multisig address.
Seller waits for a number of confirmations and then hands over or ships the product.
After receiving the product and verifying its integrity, buyer and seller sign a transaction to transfer bitcoins to the seller.
If there is a dispute, the arbitrator uses his third key to tie-break after reviewing all the evidence and following the contract.

Decentralised/social exchanges

Using a service such as Bitcoin OTC or CoinTouch, you can find friends of friends that trade crypto currency, and trade with them directly. Remember to verify the counterparty using more than one means of contact (e.g. Facebook message and phone call)

Bitcoin-OTC

The Bitcoin OTC acts as a secure 'Address Book' within the bitcoin community.

Always require the user to become registered with #bitcoin-otc.
Require a signed message from the fingerprint quoted at: http://bitcoin-otc.com/viewgpg.php
Follow additional recommendations for avoiding fraud.

Using the Web-Of-Trust

One of the key features of the Bitcoin OTC is the Web of Trust, this allows users to 'rate' each other. One can have more confidence trading with a user that has many good ratings.

http://bitcoin-otc.com/viewratings.php

Search the Bitcoin Forum for the username of the person that you are trading with. Check if the user has provided constructive and useful advice to other parties. And, most importantly, check for any claims that the user has scammed.