Prohibited changes

From Bitcoin Wiki
Revision as of 16:54, 22 March 2014 by Eldentyrell (talk | contribs) (add Demurrage, if only because namecoin is already doing it.)
Jump to: navigation, search

These changes are considered to be against the spirit of Bitcoin. Even if all Bitcoin users decide to adopt any of these changes, the resulting cryptocurrency can no longer be considered "Bitcoin" because it has diverged too much from the original design.

Require unanimous consent

These changes require the consent of every bitcoin-holder:

  • Increasing the total number of issued bitcoins beyond 21 million. Precision may be increased, but proportions must be unchanged.
  • Any rule that adds required, explicit centralization. For example, a change requiring that all blocks be signed by some central organization.
  • Demurrage (deletion or reassignment of coins judged to be "lost" or "unused"). This is highly controversial in the context of currency units; on the other hand it is absolutely essential for namespace entries like [Namecoin] (which implements Demurrage for namespace entries but not for currency units).

Require miner consensus

  • Changing the bitcoin distribution algorithm such that the subsidy at any given time period is decreased without miner consensus and 3 years notice, or increased beyond improved precision of halving (lossy beginning with block 1,890,000).


  • Adding alternatives to Proof of Work such as Proof of Stake. This could change core bitcoin too much, but with widespread agreement of some sort might be possible.

See Also

Hardfork Wishlist for hard forks that might happen and still be called "Bitcoin".