Litecoin: Difference between revisions
Removing minor criticism and linking to relevant criticism in Criticism section (take #2). Attributing opinions under criticism to their author. |
|||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
Litecoin uses Scrypt as a proof-of-work scheme. | Litecoin uses Scrypt as a proof-of-work scheme. | ||
Scrypt adds memory-intensive algorithms to reduce the efficiency of GPUs down to the level of CPUs. | Scrypt adds memory-intensive algorithms to reduce the efficiency of GPUs down to the level of CPUs. | ||
This greatly limits the ability of commodity hardware to mine at high rates | This greatly limits the ability of commodity hardware to mine at high rates. ([[#Vulnerability to mining monopoly|see criticism]]). | ||
=== Faster, Smaller Block Chain === | === Faster, Smaller Block Chain === | ||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
==Criticism== | ==Criticism== | ||
=== Redundancy === | === Redundancy === | ||
Litecoin does not provide anything significant that Bitcoin does not already provide. | ''(Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows)'' Litecoin does not provide anything significant that Bitcoin does not already provide. | ||
Because of this, and Bitcoins much greater size, it is unlikely to gain any significant momentum. | Because of this, and Bitcoins much greater size, it is unlikely to gain any significant momentum. | ||
==== Not Silver to Gold ==== | ==== Not Silver to Gold ==== | ||
Litecoin cannot be "silver to bitcoin's gold", because Bitcoin itself is both gold and silver: | ''(Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows)'' Litecoin cannot be "silver to bitcoin's gold", because Bitcoin itself is both gold and silver: | ||
While in the long-run, the BTC unit may be too valuable for everyday trade ("gold"), there are other, much smaller [[units]] that can just as well serve the purpose of "silver" while being naturally/automatically "converted" to/from BTC. | While in the long-run, the BTC unit may be too valuable for everyday trade ("gold"), there are other, much smaller [[units]] that can just as well serve the purpose of "silver" while being naturally/automatically "converted" to/from BTC. | ||
=== Vulnerability to mining monopoly === | === Vulnerability to mining monopoly === | ||
Similarly to Bitcoin, Litecoin can be attacked by a rich entity (on the scale of big corporations and governments). Also similarly to Bitcoin, this attack becomes more difficult to orchestrate the higher the hash rate of the network. However, because Litecoin is designed to be inefficient on all common computer components (both CPUs and GPUs), a malicious entity needs only produce a single piece of specialized/custom hardware to overtake all the commodity mining systems combined. | Similarly to Bitcoin, Litecoin can be attacked by a rich entity (on the scale of big corporations and governments). Also similarly to Bitcoin, this attack becomes more difficult to orchestrate the higher the hash rate of the network. ''(Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows)'' However, because Litecoin is designed to be inefficient on all common computer components (both CPUs and GPUs), a malicious entity needs only produce a single piece of specialized/custom hardware to overtake all the commodity mining systems combined. | ||
=== Pyramid scheme === | === Pyramid scheme === | ||
Since the aforementioned reasons mean Litecoin has no future potential, it effectively functions as a pyramid scheme, rewarding those who get in sooner at the expense of those who adopt it just before it finally fails (and are left with nothing). | ''(Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows)'' Since the aforementioned reasons mean Litecoin has no future potential, it effectively functions as a pyramid scheme, rewarding those who get in sooner at the expense of those who adopt it just before it finally fails (and are left with nothing). | ||
This is not the case for Bitcoin, since it has significant potential to become a long-term currency and continually be beneficial to adopters no matter when they begin using it. | This is not the case for Bitcoin, since it has significant potential to become a long-term currency and continually be beneficial to adopters no matter when they begin using it. | ||
Revision as of 03:44, 17 November 2011
What is Litecoin?
Litecoin is the result of some of the bitcoin community who joined together on IRC in an effort to create a real alternative currency similar to Bitcoin. They wanted to make a cryptocoin that is considered silver to Bitcoin's gold (see criticism).
Litecoin aims to maintain the unique traits and attributes of Bitcoin, while adding to the mixture GPU-resistant mining and a 2.5 minute block rate. This means that Litecoin doesn't have reason to compete with Bitcoin for the used up computational cycles of your graphics card, but can work independently on your processor.
Differences from Bitcoin
(Slight) Premining
Litecoin had two blocks premined, one more than the minimum single genesis block needed to start a block chain.
Scrypt Proof of Work
Litecoin uses Scrypt as a proof-of-work scheme. Scrypt adds memory-intensive algorithms to reduce the efficiency of GPUs down to the level of CPUs. This greatly limits the ability of commodity hardware to mine at high rates. (see criticism).
Faster, Smaller Block Chain
The Litecoin blockchain differs from its Bitcoin counterpart in that it tries to have smaller blocks, and generate them four times as fast as the Bitcoin network allows. This means that 1-confirmation (low value) merchants get faster confirmations for their online products, but increases the network overhead.
Total Coinage
Miners generate 50 coins per block, like Bitcoin. In light of faster blocks, to properly mimic Bitcoin's generation trajectory, the amount of coins generated gets halved every 840,000 blocks. As a result, Litecoin is scheduled to produce roughly 4 times as many coins as Bitcoin, about 82 million litecoins.
Criticism
Redundancy
(Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows) Litecoin does not provide anything significant that Bitcoin does not already provide. Because of this, and Bitcoins much greater size, it is unlikely to gain any significant momentum.
Not Silver to Gold
(Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows) Litecoin cannot be "silver to bitcoin's gold", because Bitcoin itself is both gold and silver: While in the long-run, the BTC unit may be too valuable for everyday trade ("gold"), there are other, much smaller units that can just as well serve the purpose of "silver" while being naturally/automatically "converted" to/from BTC.
Vulnerability to mining monopoly
Similarly to Bitcoin, Litecoin can be attacked by a rich entity (on the scale of big corporations and governments). Also similarly to Bitcoin, this attack becomes more difficult to orchestrate the higher the hash rate of the network. (Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows) However, because Litecoin is designed to be inefficient on all common computer components (both CPUs and GPUs), a malicious entity needs only produce a single piece of specialized/custom hardware to overtake all the commodity mining systems combined.
Pyramid scheme
(Note: Luke-Jr's opinion follows) Since the aforementioned reasons mean Litecoin has no future potential, it effectively functions as a pyramid scheme, rewarding those who get in sooner at the expense of those who adopt it just before it finally fails (and are left with nothing). This is not the case for Bitcoin, since it has significant potential to become a long-term currency and continually be beneficial to adopters no matter when they begin using it.