Talk:Segwit support

Active in column(s)

I added in the 'active in' column, since it looked like we might be getting random folks from Reddit adding themselves. Someone doesn't have to be active in core for their opinion to matter by any means, but people have been citing this document to counter the reality distortion field claiming that the developers of Bitcoin Core support "segwit2x" and getting a bunch of who-knows-who-they-are people on the page would break that purpose without something like this. The criteria I used was one commit since a year before the creation of the page which is an arbitrary but pretty low bar. A low bar is justifiable because some people contribute primarily in the form of review or long term changes that produce just a commit or two in a few months... but someone who isn't making a commit a year is really hard to argue as being part of the projects regardless of anything else. I believe if the criteria were upped to at least two the only change would be that Warren would drop out. If it were dropped to 6 months Decker would drop out (as he's busy with lightning). Both would be justifiable, as I don't consider either of them very involved right now-- but either way is fine. I just mention it to show that it's not overly sensitive to the parameter. Cheers --Gmaxwell (talk) 20:08, 11 June 2017 (UTC)

Sources Please

Please add sources for companies supporting BIP148. For example Bitstamp is not listed on coin.dance as in support.

company list

I removed the company list from the page because I don't see any evidence supporting most of the claims in it. If I were one of these companies and my position was misrepresented I would be very unhappy. Please get some actual confirmation before listing companies on the page. --Gmaxwell (talk) 07:13, 15 June 2017 (UTC)

PLEASE NOTE: This list is not yet complete, nor completely vetted by the parties listed for accuracy.

Company		Segwit itself	Deployment methods			Hardfork bundles (Silbert agreement)
		BIP 141	BIP 148	BIP 149	BIP 91	Segwit2x	COOP
Bitfury	miner	Prefer	Acceptable			Acc. until July
Bitsquare	exchange	Prefer	Prefer[1]
Coinbase	wallet	Prefer	Evaluating	Weak		Acc. until July
Xapo	wallet	Prefer	Evaluating			Acc. until July
Blockchain.info	wallet	Prefer	Evaluating	Weak		Acc. until July
Kraken	exchange	Prefer	Acceptable			Acc. until July
Bitstamp	exchange	Prefer	Acceptable			Acceptable
Bitfinex	exchange	Prefer	Acceptable			Acceptable
Bitpay	wallet	Prefer	No			Prefer
Localbitcoins	exchange	Prefer	Acceptable	Weak		Acc. until July
Poloniex	exchange	Prefer	Wanting			Acc. until July
Bitmain	miner	No	No			Prefer