Mining hardware comparison: Difference between revisions

From Bitcoin Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older editNewer edit →
No edit summary
Tybeet (talk | contribs)
Editors
30 edits
mNo edit summary
Line 3: Line 3:
The table shows (mostly) stock clock numbers. 10-20% performance improvement can be achieved via overclocking.
The table shows (mostly) stock clock numbers. 10-20% performance improvement can be achieved via overclocking.


'''Note:''' Clock refers to the Shader clock only with nVidia cards (not Core or Memory). With AMD card the shader clock is not separate.
'''Note:''' Clock refers to the Shader clock only with nVidia cards (not Core or Memory). With AMD card the shader clock is not separate, but is part of the GPU clock.


==Graphics cards==
==Graphics cards==

Revision as of 12:07, 8 May 2011

Below are some statistics about the mining performance of various hardware used in a mining rig.

The table shows (mostly) stock clock numbers. 10-20% performance improvement can be achieved via overclocking.

Note: Clock refers to the Shader clock only with nVidia cards (not Core or Memory). With AMD card the shader clock is not separate, but is part of the GPU clock.

Graphics cards

AMD

To get the maximum performance use the 2.1 release of the ATI Stream SDK. 2.2 wastes CPU time, and 2.3/2.4 drop mining performance by 5-10%.

Model Mhash/s Mhash/W W Clock SP SDK Slot Miner Notes
3XXX OpenCL Not Supported
42XX PCI-E 2.0 x16 OpenCL Not Supported (intergrated/mobile GPU)
4350 6.93 0.346 20 575 80 PCI-E 2.0 x16 poclbm -w 32, don't use vectors
4550 7.23 0.289 25 600 80 PCI-E 2.0 x16 poclbm -w 32, don't use vectors
4650 31.33 0.653 48 650 320 PCI-E 2.0 x16 poclbm -w 32, don't use vectors
4670 36.14 0.613 59 750 320 PCI-E 2.0 x16 poclbm -w 32, don't use vectors
4670 40.11 59 800 320 AGP x8 poclbm/Ubuntu 10.10 w/ H == 0 mod source -w 32 -f 0, don't use vectors
4730 72.29 0.657 110 750 640 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4770 72.29 0.904 80 750 640 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4830 55.42 0.583 95 575 640 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4850 75.30 0.685 110 625 800 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4860 67.47 0.519 130 700 640 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4870 90.36 0.602 150 750 800 2.1 PCI-E 2.0 x16 clmine
4870 78 PCI-E 2.0 x16 m0mchil's OpenCL/Vista 64bit source
4890 102.41 0.539 190 850 800 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4890 108.3 190 975 800 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4850X2 150.60 0.602 250 625 1600 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4870X2 180.72 0.632 286 750 1600 PCI-E 2.0 x16
4870X2 180.6 286 800 1600 PCI-E 2.0 x16
5450 11.99 0.631 19 650 80 PCI-E 2.1 x16
5550 40.59 1.041 39 550 320 PCI-E 2.1 x16
5570 59.96 1.538 39 650 400 PCI-E 2.1 x16
5570 64 1.641 39 650 PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil's OpenCL/WinXP source
5650 48 2.5-3.2 ? 15-19 ? PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil's OpenCL/Win7-64 source source
5670 71.49 1.117 64 775 400 PCI-E 2.1 x16
5670 72 1.64 44 850 PCI-E 2.0 x16 poclbm-mod (Win7-64) Sapphire 100287VGAL card is low power
5670 85 900 400 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm -v -f 0 -w 128
5750 116.24 1.352 86 700 720 PCI-E 2.1 x16
5750 154.56 1.45 106 830 720 PCI-E 2.1 x16 -v -w128 -f20 underclocked memory clocks from 1150MHz to 300MHz
5770 156.83 1.452 108 850 800 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 clmine
5770 180 1.406 128[*] 950 800 2.4RC1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm -v -w 128 -f 30 (*Overclocked wattage calculated here )
5770 205.58 935 300 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm 2011-04-28 -v -w 256
5830 206.64 1.181 175 800 1120 PCI-E 2.1 x16
5830 241 1.377 175 1006 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm 2011-03-11 / Win7 64
5830 245 1.4 175 880 900 2.4 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm (guiminer) -v -w 256
5830 280 993 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 phoenix 1.4 / poclbm / Win7 64 vector aggr 12, BFI_INT
5850 240.77 1.595 151 725 1440 PCI-E 2.1 x16
5850 250.26 1.657 151 725 1440 PCI-E 2.1 x16 opencl client source
5850 252 1.575 160 765 1440 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm 2011-01-25
5850 255.3 1.593 160 765 1440 2.2 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm 2011-01-25
5850 264 1.748 151 725 1440 2.4 PCI-E 1.0 x8 guiminer-20110501 -v -w128
5850 280 1.75 160 765 1440 2.2 PCI-E 2.1 x16 Phoenix 1.3 with BFI_INT
5850 292 1.825 160 765 1440 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm 2011-04-28 -v -f 1
5850 298 1.862 160 765 1440 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm 2011-04-28 -v -f 1 -w 64
5850 300 1.546 194 925 (OC) 1440 PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil's OpenCL source
5850 344 1.8594 185 890 (OC) 1440 PCI-E 2.0 x16 phoenix
5870M 116.5 ? ? ? ? 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 gui-miner (win-7)
5870 313.65 1.668 188 850 1600 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 clmine
5870 313 1.665 188 900? 1600 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 Diablo/Linux
5870 343 1.824 188 900? 1600 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 Diablo/Linux
5870 355 1.888 188 900? 1600 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm/Linux
5870 340 1.809 188 850 1600 PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil's OpenCL source
5870 360 970 700 PCI-E 2.0 x16 m0mchil's OpenCL w7-64 -f 0 -v -w 128 source
5870 385 980 1600 PCI-E 2.0 x16 poclbm-mod/Win7-64 -f 0 -v -w 128
5870 400 950 1600 2.4 PCI-E 2.0 x8 Phoenix 1.3 -k poclbm VECTORS AGGRESSION=7 FASTLOOP BFI_INT
5970 530 1.803 294 725 3200 2.4.595.10 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm/201103.beta3/Windows -v -w128 -f60
5970 535.06 1.820 294 725 3200 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 clmine
5970 560 1.905 294 725 PCI-E 2.1 x16 Diablo
5970 565 1.922 294 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 clmine2
5970 604 2.054 294 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 clmine
5970 645 1.875 344 850 3200 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil/poclbm 03-07-11 -f1, Debian 6, fglrx-driver 10.9.3
5970 740 2.1511 344 850 3200 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 phoenix/1.3 AGGRESSION=12 WORKSIZE=128 VECTORS BFI_INT, memory clock @ 300MHz
5970 755 2.2076 342 848 3200 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm 28-04-11 -f 1 -w 256 -v, Ubuntu 10.10, fglrx 11.4, memory clock @ 300MHz
5970 802 2.31 347 850 3200 2.4 PCI-E 2.1 x16 phoenix -q 6 -k poclbm AGGRESSION=19 WORKSIZE=128 BFI_INT VECTORS, Ubuntu 11.04, fglrx 11.4, memory clock @ 1000MHz
5870x2 620 850 3200 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 guiminer -v -w 128
5870x2 820 975 3200 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 phoenix/1.3 AGGRESSION=13 WORKSIZE=128 VECTORS BFI_INT Memory @ 300MHz
6310M 9.821 0.545 18 500 80 2.4 Integrated/APU poclbm-gui -v -w128 HP DM1z 18W TDP is shared with the CPU
6490M 16.289 0.708 23 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm-mod (Mac OS X 10.6.7) MacBook Pro early 2011
6850 171.59 1.351 127 775 960 2.1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 clmine
6850 196 850 960 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm -v -w 128 -f 0
6850 234.8 940 960 2.4 PCI-E 2.1 x16 Phoenix 1.3 AGGRESSION=8 WORKSIZE=128 VECTORS BFI_INT
6850 220 1.236 178[*] 1000 960 2.4RC1 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm -v -w 128 -f 30 (*Overclocked wattage calculated here )
6870 232.47 1.540 151 900 1120 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm -v -w 128
6870 277.47 940 1120 PCI-E 2.1 x16 Phoenix 1.3 AGGRESSION=8 WORKSIZE=128 VECTORS BFI_INT
6870 260.1 1.611 175 1001 1150 2.2 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm-gui windows7x86 cat 11.3 -v -w 128 -f 1
6870 267 1.768 (?) 151 (?) 900 1120 2.4 PCI-E 2.1 x16 hashkill-0.2.5 alpha cat 11.4 sdk 2.4 stock clocks, debian linux 64bit source
6870 282.23 1.611 175 1047 1120 2.2 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm windows cat 11.2 -v -w 128 -f 0 mem clock 300
6870 296 1.691 (?) 175 (?) 1000 1120 2.4 PCI-E 2.1 x16 hashkill-0.2.5 alpha cat 11.4 sdk 2.4 OC to 1000, debian linux 64bit source
6870 300 1.72 174 1038 1120 2.4 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm windows7x86 cat 11.4 -v -w128 -f1 mem clock 360, fan 100% temp 73C
6950 295 160 (?) 810 1536 2.4.595.0 PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil/poclbm 03-07-11 unlocked shaders, default mem 1250
6950 325 200 (?) 885 1536 2.4.595.0 PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil/poclbm 03-07-11 unlocked shaders, default mem 1250
6950 360 200 (?) 970 1536 2.4.595.0 PCI-E 2.1 x16 m0mchil/poclbm 03-07-11 unlocked shaders, default mem 1250
6970 323 1.468 220 880 1536 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 poclbm -w 64, SDK 2.1 not supported on 69xx.
6990 708 1.97 346 830 3072 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 mrb's hdminer source. SDK 2.1 not supported on 69xx.
6990 746 1.82 410 880 3072 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 mrb's hdminer source. SDK 2.1 not supported on 69xx.
6990 771 1.8804 410 880 3072 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 mrb's hdminer SDK 2.1 not supported on 69xx. Memory clock @ 1280Mhz.
6990 772 1.8380 420 900 3072 2.3 PCI-E 2.1 x16 Phoenix & Poclbm Overclock switch ON + overclocked to 900 mhz, VECTORS AGGRESSION=12 BFI_INT WORKSIZE=128
FirePro V8700 84.8 750 800 poclbm-mod.03.24.2011
FirePro M5800 61.4 650 poclbm-mod.03.24.2011 Ubuntu

Nvidia

Model Mhash/s Mhash/W W Clock SP Comment
8200 mGPU 1.2 1200 16 128 MB shared memory, "poclbm -w 128 -f 0"
8400 GS 2.3 "poclbm -w 128"
8600M GT 4.93 32
8600GT 5.66 1188 32
8600GT OC 7.3 1602 32 poclbm -w 128 source
8800GT 25 0.24 105 1300
8800GT 24.5 0.23 105 1300 source
8800GTS 16.8 0.109 154 source source
8800 GTS 18.7 0.124 150 1200 poclbm -w 64 no vectors
9300GE 1.57 1300 8
9300GS 1.69 1400 8
9300/nForce 730i 2.15 1200 16
9400GT 3.37 0.067 50 1400 16
9400M (MacBook) 1.90 0.32 6 700 poclbm -f 8 no vectors
9500GT 6.75 0.135 50 1400 32
9600GSO 19.88 0.237 84 1375 96
9600GSO512 11.75 0.131 90 1625 48
9600GT 15.66 0.165 95 1625 64
9600GT Zotac 15 1650 64
9600GT OC 18.8 <0.198 >95 1981 64 poclbm -w 128 -f 10 source source
9800GT 30.36 0.289 105 1800 112
9800GTX 32.54 0.232 140 1688 128
9800GTX+ 35.39 0.251 141 1836 128
9800GX2 57.83 0.294 197 2x128
9800GX2 28 0.142 197 2x128 source
G210 3.38 0.111 30.5 1402 16
G210 3.79 0.124 30.5 1402 16 poclbm -f 1
GT220 9.83 0.170 58 1360 48
GT240 19.37 0.281 69 1340 96
GT240 21.24 96 poclbm-mod -f 0 -v source
GTS250 35.39 0.244 145 1836 128
GTS250 35.2 0.243 145 1836 128
GTS250 OC 37 0.255 145 2047 128
GTX260 35.91 0.178 202 1242 192
GTX260 44 0.242 182 1242 216 source
GTX260c216 40.40 0.236 171 1242 216
GTX260c216 OC 52.0 1461 216 "poclbm -w 256 -f 1"
GTX275 50.75 0.232 219 1404 240
GTX275 58 729/1458 240 poclbm -f 0 -w 256
GTX280 46.84 0.198 236 1296 240
GTX285 53.35 0.262 204 1476 240
GTX295 89.78 0.311 289 1242 480
GT 320M (MacBook Air) 6.12 1212 48
GT 330M (Sony Vaio Z) 7.8 0.71 ( 0.3 total) 11 (26w total) 1045 48
GT430 20.24 0.413 49 1400 96
GTS450 45.28 0.427 106 1566 192
GTX460SE 56.39 0.376 150 1300 288
GTX460 68.31 0.427 160 1350 336
GTX460 (2 cards) 102 0.319? 320? 1350 source
GTX460 (2 cards) OC 127 0.374 340 1620 2x 336 rpcminer-cuda -gpugrid=128 -gputhreads=128 ver.20110227
GTX465 64.41 0.322 200 1215 352
GTX470 81.98 0.381 215 1215 448
GTX470 94.7 1414
GTX470 111.9 215 1650 448
GTX480 101.28 0.405 250 1401 480
GTX560 Ti 67.7 0.39 170 1700 384 standard EVGA 560, no overclock
GTX560 OC 86.7 <0.51 >170 1800 384 rpcminer-cuda source
GTX570 105.83 0.483 219 1464 480
GTX580 140.05 --- 244 1544 512
Quadro FX 580 5.7 0.14 40 1125 4 rpcminer-cuda, Win, -gpugrid=128 -gputhreads=512
Quadro FX 1600M 6 0.12 50 625 32 rpcminer-cuda, Win
Quadro NVS 135M 1.05 0.1 10 800 1
Quadro NVS 3100M 3.6 0.257 14 600 16 rpcminer-cuda, Win, CUDA 3.1.1
Tesla M2050 79.8 DiabloMiner

CPUs/APUs

A lot of nice data can be pulled from this thread to seed this section. Also from this page on the old wiki.

AMD

Model nprocs Mhash/s Mhash/W TDP [W] CPU Clock Mhash/s CPU Mhash/s GPU GPU GPU Clock SP Software Notes
4x Opteron 6174 48 115 0.36 320W 2.2 GHz 2.4 cpuminer v0.8.1 --alg 4way --threads 48
2x Opteron 6128 16 32.4 0.141 230W 2 GHz 32.4 0.3.19 -4way
Athlon XP 2000+ 2 0.62 0.009 70W 1.67 GHz 0.62 0.3.18/Ubuntu source source
Athlon 64 3500+ 1 1.18 0.013 89W 2.54 GHz 1.18 ufasoft v0.4 overclocked (originally 2.2 GHz)
Athlon 64 X2 3800+ 2 1.73 0.03 65 W 2.00 GHz 1.73 cpuminer (v0.8.1-1-g69529c3) -algo=4way
Athlon 64 X2 4000+ 2 1.9 0.02 65W 2.1 GHz 1.9 rpc-miner
Athlon 64 X2 4400+ 2.09 0.032 65W 2.3GHz 2.09 0.3.19/Win x64 source
Athlon 64 X2 6000+ 2 2.81 0.02 125W 3 GHz 2.81 source
Athlon 64 X2 6400+ Black Edition 2 2.9 0.023 125W 3.2 GHz 2.9 0.3.20.2 BETA/Win 7 x64 -4way
Athlon II X2 240e 2 2.71 0.06 45W 2.81 GHz 2.71 bitcoind source
Athlon II X4 630 4 10.7 0.11 95W 2.8 GHz 10.7 bitcoin-miner 0.4
Phenom II X3 720 3 3.8 0.04 95W 2.8 GHz 3.8 0.3.1x/WinXP source
Phenom II X3 720 3 7.2 0.08 95W 2.8 GHz 7.2 cpu-miner 0.2.1/WinXP source
Phenom II X4 955 4 11 0.09 125W 3.2 GHz 11 rpcminer-4way
Phenom II X4 965 4 12 0.09 140W 3.4 GHz 11 rpcminer-4way
Phenom II X6 1055T 6 15.84 0.13 125W 2.82 GHz 15.84 bitcoind source
Phenom II X6 1100T 6 22 0.176 125W 3.82 GHz 22 bitcoin-miner Aciid#bitcoin-dev
Zacate E-350 2 11 0.615 18W 1.6 Ghz 1.231 9.831 HD6310M 492 Mhz 80 poclbm -v -w128 + Ufasoft 0.7 stock speeds
Zacate E-350 2 12 1.648 Ghz 1.252 10.87 HD6310M 492 Mhz 80 poclbm -v -w 256 -f 1 "autotune" speed with ASUS EFI BIOS

Intel

Model p/t Mhash/s Mhash/W ACP [W] Clock Version Comment
Pentium III mobile ? 1 0.3 0.014 21W 1.07 GHz 0.3.1x/Win2K source source
Old Xeon 512k (Dual) 2x1/2 2.0 ? ? 3.06GHz cpuminer (v0.8.1-1-g69529c3) HT disabled, algo=4way (twice as fast as the 2nd best algo)
Pentium 4 2.0A 1 0.85 2.0 GHz ufasoft-0.4/WinXP -g no -t 2
Pentium Dual-Core E5400 2/2 2.27 0.03 65W 2.7 GHz bitcoind source
Celeron E330 2/2 2.2 0.03 65W 2.5 GHz 0.3.19/Ubuntu10.04 source
Core 2 Quad Q9400 4/4 4.35 0.046 95W 2.66 GHz
Core i3 530 2/4 8.31 0.10 80W 3.66 GHz Ufasoft 0.7 -v -a5 -g no -t 4
Core i3 M350 2/4 1.48 0.04 35W 2.27 GHz bitcoind source
Core i5 M450 2/4 1.8 0.05 35W 1.2 GHz 0.3.17/Win7-54 source
Core i5-650 2/4 5.1 0.04 ? 3.2 GHz cpuminer-0.7 -4way
Core i5 ? 4/? 6.5 client from svn source
Core i5-2400 4/4 4.5 0.05 95W 3.1 GHz cpuminer git (2011-01-22) cryptopp_asm32
Core i5-2400 4/4 14 0.15 95W 3.1 GHz cpuminer git (2011-03-26) sse2_64
Core i7 920 4/8 19.2 0.10 195 4.0 GHz (x21) ufasoft -a 5
Core i7 950 4/8 5.88 0.039 150W 3.83 GHz (x23) bitcoin-0.3.20.2 Win7-64
Core i7 950 4/8 18.9 0.126 150W 3.83 GHz (x23) ufasoft v0.4
Core i7 980x 6/12 19.2 0.15 130 4.4 GHz (x33) cpuminer/Win7-64
Core i7 980x 6/12 8.7 3.9 GHz (x27) 0.3.17/Win7-64
Core i7 620M 2/4 6.3 0.18 35 2.66 GHz ufasoft v0.4
Core 2 Duo E6550 1/2 2.45 ? ? 2.33 GHz cpuminer 0.7.1 (Linux) --algo=sse2_64
Core 2 Duo E6850 2/2 6.75 0.10 65W 3.0 Ghz ufasoft-0.3
Core 2 Duo E7300 2/2 7.76 0.11 70W 3.33 GHz (o/c?) ufasoft-0.3 miner optimized for Intel Core
Core 2 Duo E7300 2/2 2.52 0.04 65W 2.66 GHz bitcoind source
Xeon 3060 1/2 2.03 0.03 65W 2.4GHz cpuminer 0.8.1 (Linux) --algo=cryptopp_asm32
Xeon Prestonia 2.4 (dual) 2x1/2 2.16 0.017 130W 2.4 GHz ufasoft v0.4
Xeon X5355 (dual) 2x4/4 10.13 0.16 120W 2.66GHz bitcoind Roughly the same speed as the "c" algo in cpuminer
Xeon X5355 (dual) 2x4/4 22.76 0.09 120W 2.66GHz cpuminer (v0.8.1-1-g69529c3) -O2 -march=core2, algo=sse2_64
Xeon E5440 4/8 7.3 ? 80W 2.66 GHz Kiv's poclbm-gui FIXME: Either wrong model # or wrong threads/speed info
Xeon E5520 4/8 6.5 0.08 80W 2.27 GHz bitcoind source
Xeon E5530 4/8 7.14 0.09 80W 2.4 GHz bitcoind source
Xeon E5630 (dual) 2x4/8 8 0.1 80W 2.53 GHz 0.3.17/Win7-64 source
Atom N270 1 0.42 0.17 2.5W 1.6 GHz 0.3.1x/WinXP source

Other Devices

Consoles

Device p/t Mhash/s Mhash/W ACP [W] Clock Version Comment
Sony Playstation 3 (FAT) 6 21 0.35 60W 3.2 GHz cellminer Needs custom firmware (no links to it, potential issues with Sony assholes.) source source Total power usage of PS3 fat is 120W but only the Cell cpu is active.
Sony Playstation 3 (SLIM) 6 21 0.7 35W 3.2 GHz cellminer Total power usage of PS3 slim is 70W but only the Cell cpu is active.

ARM devices

Model p/t Mhash/s Mhash/W ACP [W] Clock Version Comment
Cortex A8 1 0.125 0.36 0.35 W 0.6 GHz cpuminer git (2011-03-26) Nokia N900: 'cryptopp'
Cortex A8 1 0.2 0.57 0.35 W 0.6 GHz cpuminer git (2011-03-26) Nokia N900: 'c' algo
Tegra 250 (2xCortex-A9) 2 0.57 1.14 0.5 W 1.0 GHz cpuminer git (2011-03-24) Toshiba AC100, ubuntu, 'c' algo


See Also

Retrieved from "https://en.bitcoin.it/w/index.php?title=Mining_hardware_comparison&oldid=8134"