Covenants support: Difference between revisions

From Bitcoin Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
โ† Older editNewer edit โ†’
Bit (talk | contribs)
1 edit
mNo edit summary
1440000bytes (talk | contribs)
Editors, Permittors
20 edits
split the table in 2 sections (w/ and w/o rationale)
Line 53: Line 53:
|-
|-
| arbedout || Sigbash || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/arbedout/94a7350d2a521e42a70ddf9c3f2ce469 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
| arbedout || Sigbash || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/arbedout/94a7350d2a521e42a70ddf9c3f2ce469 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| ArminSabouri || OP_CAT || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{No}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} ||
|-
|-
| benthecarman || Taproot Wizards || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://x.com/benthecarman/status/1867275434376777930 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
| benthecarman || Taproot Wizards || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://x.com/benthecarman/status/1867275434376777930 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
Line 63: Line 61:
|-
|-
| chrisguida || Lightning || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{No}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Prefer}} || [https://gist.github.com/chrisguida/85fc0bc4173b9f339c7d8790d728a851 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
| chrisguida || Lightning || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{No}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Prefer}} || [https://gist.github.com/chrisguida/85fc0bc4173b9f339c7d8790d728a851 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| instagibbs || Spiral || {{Weak}} || {{Wanting}} || {{No}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/instagibbs/eeb9d8013270387b4318b5585e858b9c ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| jamesob || ??? || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/jamesob/9c0985c0f3f7bef6e5680e8460d85b3d ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| matthewjablack || Atomic Finance || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Weak}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/matthewjablack/ada1794d8e66bcf6ba4175eeea54501c ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| moonsettler || LNhance || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}}<ref name="reardenvault"/> || {{Wanting}}<ref name="reardenvault"/> || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/moonsettler/76654ca714fac03d9e08da3e47e98b98 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| Orkun Kฤฑlฤฑรง || Citrea || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/orkunkilic/c8e21920d52f9669daf9b8c5c86daa0c ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| Psifour || Taproot Wizards || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Weak}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/Psifour/6cba4b6f0fe0ca6dd8d1aa84c878f9ff ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| Paul Sztorc || Drivechain || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Weak}} || [https://www.truthcoin.info/files/covenants-rationale/ ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| Trey Del Bonis || Alpen Labs || {{No|No*}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || [https://gist.github.com/delbonis/14d1802cf4b90439552e61e4cade3a7d ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
! colspan="12" style="background-color:#f2f2f2; text-align:center;" | Without a rationale
|-
| ArminSabouri || OP_CAT || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{No}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} ||
|-
|-
| Cyimon Chen || Fiamma || {{No}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} ||
| Cyimon Chen || Fiamma || {{No}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} ||
Line 77: Line 95:
|-
|-
| fi3 || DEMAND || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
| fi3 || DEMAND || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
|-
|-
| instagibbs || Spiral || {{Weak}} || {{Wanting}} || {{No}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/instagibbs/eeb9d8013270387b4318b5585e858b9c ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| jamesob || ??? || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/jamesob/9c0985c0f3f7bef6e5680e8460d85b3d ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
|-
| jaybny || Sidepit || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{No}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
| jaybny || Sidepit || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{No}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
Line 94: Line 107:
|-
|-
| Luke Dashjr || Bitcoin Knots || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{No}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
| Luke Dashjr || Bitcoin Knots || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{No}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
|-
| matthewjablack || Atomic Finance || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Weak}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/matthewjablack/ada1794d8e66bcf6ba4175eeea54501c ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| moonsettler || LNhance || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Wanting}}<ref name="reardenvault"/> || {{Wanting}}<ref name="reardenvault"/> || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/moonsettler/76654ca714fac03d9e08da3e47e98b98 ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
|-
| Nick Hansen || Luxor || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} ||
| Nick Hansen || Luxor || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} ||
|-
|-
| notasithlord || Hydra Host / Turing Games || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Weak}} ||
| notasithlord || Hydra Host / Turing Games || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Weak}} ||
|-
| Orkun Kฤฑlฤฑรง || Citrea || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/orkunkilic/c8e21920d52f9669daf9b8c5c86daa0c ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| Psifour || Taproot Wizards || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Weak}} || {{Weak}} || [https://gist.github.com/Psifour/6cba4b6f0fe0ca6dd8d1aa84c878f9ff ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
| Paul Sztorc || Drivechain || {{Acceptable}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Weak}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Weak}} || [https://www.truthcoin.info/files/covenants-rationale/ ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
|-
| ProofOfKeags || Alpen Labs || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} ||
| ProofOfKeags || Alpen Labs || {{Acceptable}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} ||
Line 122: Line 125:
|-
|-
| Steven Roose || Second (Ark) || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{No}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
| Steven Roose || Second (Ark) || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{No}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Acceptable}} ||
|-
| Trey Del Bonis || Alpen Labs || {{No|No*}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Prefer}} || [https://gist.github.com/delbonis/14d1802cf4b90439552e61e4cade3a7d ๐Ÿ“Œ]
|-
|-
| xhliu || sCrypt || {{Weak}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Deficient}} ||
| xhliu || sCrypt || {{Weak}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Evaluating}} || {{Wanting}} || {{Prefer}} || {{Weak}} || {{Deficient}} || {{Acceptable}} || {{Deficient}} ||

Revision as of 11:01, 16 December 2024


This list is incomplete and under construction. Evaluation without a rationale will be ignored.

Evaluating Not sure and still evaluating the idea
No Doesn't support
Deficient Okay with the idea, but considers it to have insufficient community support
Weak Better than nothing at all
Wanting Positively likes the idea, but considers it to have insufficient community support
Acceptable It is a workable solution
Prefer The best option all things considered

Developers

Developer Affiliation LNHANCE OP_CAT OP_CCV OP_VAULT OP_TXHASH SIGHASH_APO Rationale
OP_CTV OP_CSFS OP_PAIRCOMMIT OP_INTERNALKEY
1440000bytes joinstr Prefer Acceptable No Acceptable Deficient Evaluating Acceptable No No ๐Ÿ“Œ
Alexei Zamyatin BOB Weak Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating ๐Ÿ“Œ
arbedout Sigbash Acceptable Wanting Evaluating Wanting Acceptable Evaluating Wanting Wanting Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
benthecarman Taproot Wizards Prefer Prefer Acceptable Prefer Prefer Wanting Wanting Wanting Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
bit Ducat Protocol Prefer Prefer No Evaluating Prefer Prefer No Evaluating Evaluating ๐Ÿ“Œ
Ben Zhu Discoco Labs Prefer Acceptable No No Prefer Evaluating Acceptable Wanting No ๐Ÿ“Œ
chrisguida Lightning Prefer Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable No Deficient Deficient Deficient Prefer ๐Ÿ“Œ
instagibbs Spiral Weak Wanting No Wanting Wanting Evaluating Wanting Wanting Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
jamesob ??? Prefer Prefer Weak Prefer Acceptable Wanting Acceptable Deficient Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
matthewjablack Atomic Finance Prefer Acceptable Weak Acceptable Wanting Evaluating Acceptable Wanting Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
moonsettler LNhance Prefer Prefer Prefer Prefer Wanting Wanting[1] Wanting[1] Wanting Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
Orkun Kฤฑlฤฑรง Citrea Acceptable Wanting No No Prefer Evaluating Deficient Prefer Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
Psifour Taproot Wizards Prefer Prefer Weak Acceptable Prefer Deficient Deficient Weak Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
Paul Sztorc Drivechain Acceptable Wanting Weak Wanting Acceptable Evaluating Prefer Deficient Weak ๐Ÿ“Œ
Trey Del Bonis Alpen Labs No* Prefer Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Prefer ๐Ÿ“Œ
Without a rationale
ArminSabouri OP_CAT Acceptable Prefer Evaluating Prefer Prefer Evaluating No Prefer Weak
Cyimon Chen Fiamma No Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Acceptable Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating
cryptoquick Surmount Systems Acceptable Prefer Evaluating Prefer Acceptable Evaluating Acceptable Prefer No
Eli Ben-Sasson StarkWare Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating
Ethan Heilman OP_CAT Prefer Prefer Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating Prefer Prefer Evaluating
Evan Kaloudis ZEUS Prefer Wanting Weak Acceptable No Acceptable Prefer Deficient Prefer
everythingsats African Bitcoiners Prefer Prefer Acceptable Prefer Acceptable Wanting Prefer Acceptable Acceptable
fi3 DEMAND Wanting Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Deficient Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Acceptable
jaybny Sidepit Prefer Prefer Acceptable Prefer Deficient Acceptable Wanting No Acceptable
Jon Atack Bitcoin Core Acceptable Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating
Kevin He Bitlayer Evaluating Acceptable Evaluating Evaluating Acceptable Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating
knocte geewallet No Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating No Evaluating No No Prefer
LucidLuckylee ZeroSync No Acceptable No No Weak Evaluating Weak Prefer Weak
Luke Dashjr Bitcoin Knots Acceptable Wanting Evaluating No Deficient Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Acceptable
Nick Hansen Luxor Prefer Prefer Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating Acceptable Wanting Weak
notasithlord Hydra Host / Turing Games Prefer Prefer Evaluating Wanting Acceptable Evaluating Prefer Evaluating Weak
ProofOfKeags Alpen Labs Acceptable Prefer Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Weak
reardencode LNHANCE Prefer Prefer Acceptable Prefer Wanting Wanting[1] Wanting[1] Deficient No
Rob Hamilton AnchorWatch Prefer Prefer Wanting Prefer Wanting Evaluating Acceptable Wanting Weak
RobinLinus Stanford / BitVM No Acceptable Evaluating Evaluating No Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Weak
roujiamo bitdollar Weak Acceptable Evaluating Wanting Prefer Weak Deficient Acceptable Deficient
Simanta Gautam Alpen Labs Weak Acceptable Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Weak Deficient Prefer Weak
Steven Roose Second (Ark) Prefer Prefer Evaluating Deficient Prefer Acceptable No Prefer Acceptable
xhliu sCrypt Weak Acceptable Evaluating Wanting Prefer Weak Deficient Acceptable Deficient
Yovela Luo Fiamma No Evaluating Evaluating Evaluating Acceptable Evaluating Evaluating Prefer Evaluating
ZmnSCPxj C= Wanting Weak Wanting Wanting Deficient Evaluating Deficient Wanting Wanting
  1. โ†‘ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Only one of CCV and VAULT should be implemented, as they enable nearly identical constructions
Retrieved from "https://en.bitcoin.it/w/index.php?title=Covenants_support&oldid=70478"