NotATether: Create Full RBF stub: mempool policy vs BIP125 opt-in; Core 24/28/29 history; link Replace by fee / Mempool / Fee estimation / Package relay (no Package RBF page)

2026-09-12T13:22:36Z

Create Full RBF stub: mempool policy vs BIP125 opt-in; Core 24/28/29 history; link Replace by fee / Mempool / Fee estimation / Package relay (no Package RBF page)

New page

'''Full RBF''' (full replace-by-fee) is a [[Mempool|mempool]] policy in which a node accepts a replacement for an unconfirmed transaction even when the original did not signal replaceability under BIP 125. It is a relay and mining policy, not a consensus rule. Nodes that do not implement full RBF still accept blocks that contain replacements. It is one variant of [[Replace by fee]]; other historical variants include opt-in RBF, first-seen-safe RBF, and delayed RBF.

Bitcoin Core historically applied a first-seen rule: once a transaction was in the mempool, a conflicting higher-fee transaction was ignored unless the original had opted in. BIP 125, deployed in Bitcoin Core 0.12.0, defined that opt-in: a transaction signals replaceability when any of its inputs has <code>nSequence</code> less than <code>0xffffffff−1</code> (see [[nSequence]]). Wallets that wanted to bump fees set the signal. Wallets that wanted to present an unconfirmed output as final left it unset. The first-seen simplification never bound miners: a miner could always include a higher-fee conflict. As more hash power and more relay nodes treated unsignaled replacements as acceptable, the opt-in bit stopped predicting whether an unconfirmed transaction would remain first.

Under full RBF, replacement is still subject to the rest of the node's replacement rules: the replacement must pay a higher absolute fee, a sufficiently higher fee rate, and must not cause unbounded mempool churn (the familiar BIP 125 incentive constraints, with details revised over time). The change is only that the original transaction's signaling is not required. The policy is local. A node with full RBF will relay and, if mining, consider the higher-fee transaction. A node without it will keep the first-seen transaction and will not relay the conflict. Compact block reconstruction is more reliable among nodes that share the same replacement policy.

Full RBF does not make unconfirmed transactions safe. It makes the unsafety uniform: any unconfirmed output can be replaced by a higher-fee double spend that the network is willing to relay. Services that credit unconfirmed deposits do so at their own risk regardless of signaling. Wallets that need to increase a stuck transaction's fee can do so without having set the BIP 125 bit at first broadcast, provided enough of the relay network and miners apply full RBF. Related package policies (limited package RBF, [[TRUC]] / v3 transactions) are separate rules about replacing clusters of related transactions; they are not implied by full RBF alone. See [[Package relay]] and [[Replace by fee]].

Bitcoin Core 24.0 added the <code>mempoolfullrbf</code> configuration option, defaulting to off (opt-in RBF only). Bitcoin Core 28.0 changed the default to on. Bitcoin Core 29.0 removed the option, making full replace-by-fee the only mempool replacement policy in Core. The Core wallet has defaulted to creating opt-in RBF transactions for some time. Full RBF affects how the node treats transactions created by others, not only its own wallet. Because policy is not consensus, effective network behaviour still depends on what miners currently run.

== See also ==
* [[Replace by fee]]
* [[Mempool]]
* [[Fee estimation]]
* [[Package relay]]
* [[nSequence]]
* [[TRUC]]

== External links ==
* [https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0125.mediawiki BIP 125: Opt-in Full Replace-by-Fee Signaling]
* [https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/doc/policy/mempool-replacements.md Bitcoin Core mempool replacement policy]
* [https://bitcoinops.org/en/topics/replace-by-fee/ Bitcoin Optech: Replace by fee]
* [https://bitcoincore.org/en/releases/24.0.1/ Bitcoin Core 24.0.1 release notes (<code>mempoolfullrbf</code>)]
* [https://bitcoincore.org/en/releases/28.0/ Bitcoin Core 28.0 release notes (default on)]
* [https://bitcoincore.org/en/releases/29.0/ Bitcoin Core 29.0 release notes (option removed)]

[[Category:Technical]]

Full RBF - Revision history

NotATether: Create Full RBF stub: mempool policy vs BIP125 opt-in; Core 24/28/29 history; link Replace by fee / Mempool / Fee estimation / Package relay (no Package RBF page)